Memberships open November 23. Get on the list and receive the free Rebuild Your Credit ebook today.

Join the launch list →
All articles

Secured vs Unsecured Credit Cards in Canada: Which Builds Credit Faster?

Short answer: Secured and unsecured credit cards build credit at the same speed in Canada, because both send the same kind of monthly account to the credit bureaus. The real difference is approval. A secured card takes a refundable deposit instead of a credit history, so a damaged or empty file can start reporting this month instead of waiting on an unsecured approval that may never come.

What is the difference between a secured and an unsecured credit card?

The difference is the deposit: a secured credit card is backed by money you hand the issuer before the account opens, and an unsecured credit card is backed by nothing except the issuer's read of your credit file.

A secured credit card is a real credit card — a credit limit, a monthly statement, a due date, and interest on any balance you carry — that the issuer protects by holding a refundable security deposit. According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, issuers "normally set your credit limit at an amount that is equal to or higher than your deposit", the deposit "may range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars", and if you miss payments the issuer "may use your deposit to pay the money you owe". An unsecured credit card is the ordinary kind: the issuer carries the risk itself, decides on your credit history and income, and holds no deposit.

Both land on your credit report as a revolving tradeline. A tradeline is one credit account on your file, carrying its credit limit, its balance, its payment status and the date it opened. Neither Equifax Canada nor TransUnion Canada scores an account differently for having a deposit behind it — the account is judged on its limit, its balance and its payment record, which is the mechanism our guide to how a secured credit card works walks through step by step.

Which builds credit faster, a secured card or an unsecured card?

Neither is faster. Two cards with the same limit, the same balance and the same on-time payments move a credit score by the same amount, whether or not a deposit sits behind one of them.

What sets the pace is when the first report lands and how clean the payments are afterwards. According to TransUnion Canada, payment history is "typically the most important aspect of your credit score", and length of credit history — how long your accounts have been open — is one of the factors behind a score that usually runs between 300 and 900. A card approved and reporting in February beats a better card you are still waiting for in June.

So the useful question is not which card is stronger. It is which card will say yes this week. For a file with collections, a completed consumer proposal, or no history at all, the secured card usually says yes and the unsecured card usually does not — and a card you do not hold reports nothing at all. Readers rebuilding after an insolvency filed with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy can see the full sequence in our guide to rebuilding credit after a consumer proposal.

Secured vs unsecured credit cards in Canada, side by side

The table below sets out what each kind of card asks of you and what it sends to the credit bureaus, with the AvenaCredit card shown in its own column so you can see where it lands.

What mattersSecured credit cardUnsecured credit cardAvenaCredit secured card
Security depositRequired and refundable; a few hundred to a few thousand dollars (FCAC)NoneRefundable, $250 to $5,000, set by you
Credit check to applyVaries by issuer: some run a hard check, some verify identity onlyA hard credit check in almost every caseNo credit check, only an identity check at sign-up
Credit limitNormally equal to or higher than the deposit (FCAC)Set by the issuer from your file and incomeEqual to the deposit you choose
Who gets approvedThin files, damaged files, newcomers, people rebuilding after bankruptcy (FCAC)Files with an established payment recordAnyone who passes identity verification
What the bureaus receiveA revolving tradeline, if the issuer reports — confirm before you applyA revolving tradeline from every mainstream Canadian issuerA revolving tradeline reported to Equifax Canada
Upfront cashThe deposit, plus any one-time set-up fee (FCAC)NoneThe deposit only
Ongoing costAn annual fee is commonAnywhere from no fee to a premium annual fee$9.99 a month on its own

One line in that table decides more than the rest: whether the issuer reports at all. A deposit-backed card that never files with a bureau is a spending tool, not a credit-building tool, and the only reliable way to know is to read the issuer's own terms before you hand over money.

AvenaCredit's own card sits squarely in the secured column — a refundable deposit you set between $250 and $5,000, reported to Equifax Canada, with no credit check on the card itself. You can see the current terms on the page for the AvenaCredit secured Mastercard.

Can you get an unsecured credit card with bad credit in Canada?

Occasionally yes, but the unsecured cards that open to a damaged file are the costly end of the market: small limits, monthly or annual fees, and interest at the top of the range. The trade is simple — you keep your cash, and you pay for the privilege every month.

Two warnings are worth more than any shortlist. Cards advertised as "guaranteed approval" still verify who you are, and some charge a one-time set-up fee that, according to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, is separate from any deposit and "you may not get it back if your application is declined". And a prepaid card is not credit at all: no limit, no borrowing, nothing to report.

If the worry behind the question is the application itself — whether a secured card will put a hard inquiry on your file, and whether you can be turned down — that question has its own answer, issuer by issuer, in do secured credit cards run a credit check in Canada.

How much does a secured credit card cost in Canada?

Expect two separate numbers: the deposit, which is your own money held and returned, and the fees, which are not. According to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, a secured card "may have an annual fee", and you may also pay a one-time application or set-up fee that is separate from the deposit. When you close the card and clear the balance, the deposit comes back.

The deposit is the part people get wrong, in both directions. Too small and the card does not cover an ordinary week of spending; too large and cash you need is locked away for a year or more. The practical test is your normal monthly card spending, not a round number.

Here is the one thing we can say from inside AvenaCredit, because it is how the product is wired rather than a claim about results: the account we file is a line of credit reported to Equifax Canada alone, and the first report appears 30 to 45 days after the first payment. The secured card is reported as a second account alongside it. Two reported accounts on a thin file is credit mix and payment history at the same time — which is why the calendar, not the card type, decides how soon a file starts to read like a credit history.

How do you use either card so your score actually moves?

The routine is identical for both kinds of card, and it is short.

  1. Pay on time, every month, without exception. Equifax Canada puts it plainly: pay at least the minimum payment, on time, every month. One missed payment does more damage than a year of careful use repairs.
  2. Keep the statement balance well under the limit. Credit utilization is the share of your available credit you are using at the moment the bureau takes its snapshot. Equifax Canada and TransUnion Canada both suggest staying below about 35% of your limit, and many Canadian lenders work to a tighter target than that.
  3. Use the card for ordinary purchases. Groceries, gas, a phone bill, a streaming subscription — a card that sits in a drawer gives the bureau nothing to report. Put real spending on it and pay the statement off.
  4. Leave the account open. TransUnion Canada suggests keeping your oldest account open to lengthen your period of active credit use. Closing a card shortens your history and shrinks your available credit at the same time.
  5. Check the report, do not guess. Pull your Equifax Canada file after the second statement and confirm the account is there, with the right limit and an R1 payment rating.

If what you want is the account reporting rather than the shopping, the deposit-backed card can also arrive as part of a plan: the AvenaCredit secured card is included free with Boost at $84.99 a month, which also reports rent and utility payments including phone bills, and backdates up to two years of rent. Build is $34.99 a month with rent and utility reporting; Starter is $24.99 a month for the reported line of credit on its own. The membership plans involve no hard credit check, and the card itself has no credit check at all — only an identity check at sign-up. You can see what each plan reports before you decide which one fits.

Who should skip a secured card

Skip it if you already hold an unsecured card that reports and is in good standing. A second card does not double your progress, and the deposit is better left in your account.

Skip it too if the deposit would come out of rent or grocery money. Locking up $500 you need in three weeks to improve a number you will not use for a year is the wrong order of operations, and a reported account that costs nothing upfront does the same job. Readers starting from nothing rather than rebuilding will find the ranked options, free ones included, in our guide to fixing a thin credit file. And if you have an active consumer proposal, check with your administrator before you open any new credit.

For most people in between — a file with late payments behind it, or no file at all — the deposit-backed card is simply the one that gets approved, and getting approved is the whole game. Read which credit cards a damaged file can actually get and how long to hold a secured card before graduating, then compare the three plans to see whether the card on its own or a plan with it included is the better buy.

Next step: If your file is thin or damaged and no unsecured card will approve you, the move is a deposit-backed card that reports — not another application that ends in a decline. The AvenaCredit secured Mastercard reports to Equifax Canada with a deposit you set from $250, no credit check and only an identity check at sign-up; join the launch list to get the card at launch.

Common questions

Does a secured credit card build credit faster than an unsecured one?

No. A secured card and an unsecured card with the same limit, balance and on-time payments move a credit score by the same amount. The deposit protects the issuer, not your score. Where a secured card wins is approval: it can start reporting to Equifax Canada now, while an unsecured application on a damaged file is usually declined.

Do secured credit cards report to both Equifax and TransUnion in Canada?

It depends entirely on the issuer, so check the terms before you pay a deposit. Some Canadian secured cards report to both Equifax Canada and TransUnion Canada, some to one only. The AvenaCredit secured card reports to Equifax Canada. A deposit-backed card that reports to no bureau will not build credit, however carefully you use it.

Can I get an unsecured credit card to rebuild credit after a consumer proposal?

Rarely, and not quickly. A completed consumer proposal stays on an Equifax Canada report for three years after completion or six years from filing, whichever comes first, and most unsecured issuers decline while it is showing. A secured card or a reported line of credit builds the new payment history that later unsecured approvals depend on.

How much deposit should I put on a secured credit card?

Size the deposit to what you normally spend on a card in a month, so everyday purchases fit on it. Canadian secured cards generally accept a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, and the AvenaCredit card takes $250 to $5,000. A deposit too small to cover groceries and gas defeats the point.

Will applying for a secured credit card hurt my credit score?

Only if the issuer runs a hard credit check, which shows as an inquiry and accounts for roughly 10% of a score. Some Canadian issuers run one, others verify identity only, so confirm on the issuer's own site as of 2026. The AvenaCredit secured card has no credit check, only an identity check at sign-up, so applying adds no inquiry.

See more AvenaCredit articles on Google

Add us as a preferred source and our articles are more likely to show up when you search on Google.

Add as a preferred source on Google
RS
Written byRaben Sim

Content creator at AvenaCredit, writing about Canadian credit scores, credit building and rent reporting. Spot something wrong or out of date? Email info@avenacredit.com.

Ready to build your credit?

One payment a month, reported to Equifax Canada. No hard credit check, no loan, no interest.

See plans